Grape Introspections

Author: Brian Croser
Source: Jancis Robinson
Review Date: Nov 2013

This essay also appears on Jancis Robinson’s site at:

Barring global financial accidents, geopolitical upheaval or an asteroid strike, 2014 should be a good business year propelled by the gathering momentum of the US economy, which should also tame our dollar. Fine wine is at the forefront of consumption growth and the US has a structural deficiency of grape supply. I am in Oregon observing the ramping up of fruit, land and vineyard prices.

Australia finally has a business friendly government and the season looks like being kind based on long-term weather forecasts and our wet winter past. 

Can we take advantage of the opportunity of the global tightening of supply and the increasing appetite of the US and China for fine wine?

Jancis Robinson just quoted a prevailing attitude in New York that Southern Hemisphere wines are out of fashion yet the wines of Australia, New Zealand, Chile, Argentina and South Africa have never been better, and Australian wines keep sweeping the competitions against Northern and Southern hemisphere competitors. 

What’s the problem?

Answer: we have poor image in those attributes that most count for fine wine. Our terroir credentials are distorted by Australia’s hot dry climate profile, suitable only for over-ripe Shiraz and by the corporate industrial image of our producers. We compound the image problem by constantly treating our industry like an infectious disease patient, that needs continual monitoring, diagnosing and finally the public wringing of hands and global announcement that the patient is in terminal decline in isolation.

How can we convince the discriminating fine wine consumers of the globe, seeking quality, prestige and the dignity of a great provenance or terroir when we are telling the world our industry is a basket case.  

Australia has great diverse natural advantages for wine production, unequalled quality of human capital for the production of fine wine and an enviable isolation from the pollution pressures of the great population concentrations of the globe. The rapid planting of cool climate, highly differentiated terroirs in South-eastern Australia through the ’90’s has been blamed for Australia’s grape oversupply and all of the handwringing economic malaise that has followed. Those same vineyards, now mature and doing their best work, represent a great opportunity in the global battle for a share of the fine wine market. But only if we achieve a complete inversion of our self destructive, forensic public analysis of our wine community’s perceived problems.

We should be proclaiming our outstanding fine wine strengths not decrying our short term supply excesses and exciting the ages old war of words between the hot irrigation dependent branded commodity grape and wine producers and the fine wine producers of Australia’s cooler regions.

I lament the lost opportunity of the past decade to build Australia’s fine wine reputation on the solid foundation of scientifically exploring and patiently explaining our great terroirs to the fine wine community of the world.  Our industry leadership is caught between the volume imperatives of the few branded commodity wine producers and the very many diverse disorganised and struggling small fine wine producers who have limited political and financial clout. The branded commodity wine producers of Australia are facing extreme competition from low cost producers like Chile, where labour is $2.50/hour and are penalised by Australia’s escalating costs where labour is more like $25/hour, penalties exacerbated by bureaucratic impediments to doing business. Our small producers with few exceptions do not have the global fine wine image or international respect to excite the price multiplier that is required to reinvest in quality improvement as is happening in Oregon, California and New Zealand.

Yet Australia’s fine wine quality remains at a very high level.

Industry leadership has retreated to the safe territory of appeasement of the large producers, pacifying the small and justifying all by the apparently corporately sound management practice of measuring all that can be measured and using the past as the template for the future.

We cannot capture the fine wine future by pulling out those vines condemned by committee to achieve an artificial balance of supply and demand.

The fine wine future can only be only be realised by proclaiming our great terroirs and the wines produced from them and portraying a future where Australian fine wine prices will justify determined reinvestment in the improvement of quality in our vineyards wrought by better rootstocks and clones on closer spacing, managed meticulously by highly selective mechanisation.

Real industry leadership would have recognised the essential dichotomy of Australian wine, all wine, a decade ago and would by now have convinced a significant cohort of the globe’s fine wine consumers that Australian fine wine is a worthy alternative to Bordeaux, Burgundy, Oregon and Napa especially in the failing markets of the US and UK. One strategy for fine wine and another for branded commodity wine recognising the very different attributes and markets of each, eliminating the public bad temper between the hot, irrigation dependent, riparian vineyards of Australia and the swath of genuine cool and moderate climate vineyards of Australia’s coastline.

The real and enduring structural commodity grape surpluses in the European wine countries does not interfere in the public mind with the perception of the scarce fine wines of Bordeaux, Burgundy, Riocha or Barolo. They are not perceived as the same product from the same industry despite being made from grapes from the same country. 

Meanwhile the Languedoc which is perceived as a large flat hot vineyard region in continuous oversupply cannot achieve the image differentiation for the fine wines from its many and varied genuine fine wine terroirs. Languedoc is a European metaphor for Australia.

Current industry leadership is not visionary it is corporate and for political convenience it is revisionary. Appeasement of the commodity wine producers and the political compromise of treating all Australian wine the same has been achieved at a fearful cost to our 3000 small and medium sized fine wine producers over the past decade.

It is amusing to see how resilient and obdurately resistant the cool climate vignerons of Australia are to the incessant appeals of industry leadership to pull out 20% to 30% of their vines. It is so frustrating to the industry leaders analysing the statistics of the past that these economically illiterate vignerons cannot see the errors of their past and root up their dreams today and forget their aspirations to achieve the same quality, image, recognition and prices in the global fine wine market place as the French, Californians, Oregonians and others.

Where among our public industry leaders is there a passionate hands on fine wine producer exciting the global fine wine community to join us in our vision of Australia as a leader of fine wine quality achievement? Just watch Aurelio Montes as the leader of the Chilean fine wine industry and the difference he will make to the perception of Chilean fine wine. Vision and image are necessary amplifiers of real terroir and wine quality and we lack those amplifiers.

Whether it is diluting the WET tax advantage for small producers or contemplating an excise demanded by the beer and spirit dominated corporate wine producers of Australia or attacking the supermarket duopoly, the agenda of industry leadership largely serves those large corporations. When Australian fine wine excites the same global competition as the French or as the Californians from the US market, the supermarkets will be only too willing to pay for and respect properly Australian fine wine. May that day arrive quickly but it won’t arrive at all without some courageous, visionary and visible industry leadership, and please no more introspective reports.

BJC. 30/10/2013.

Don't miss out on the next vintage of Tapanappa Chardonnays again!

Sign up for Tappening Newsletter and be the first to receive information on our newest releases, upcoming events and much more.

Sorry we have to ask

To enter this site you must be at least 18 years old.

By clicking enter, I certify that I am over the age of 18.